Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, a hidden gem in Middleburg, FL, where culinary traditions blend seamlessly with modern flair. This delightful establishment is celebrated for its extensive menu, designed to satisfy every craving.
- Appetizers: Start your journey with their renowned Garlic Cheese Bread or delve into flavors with Shrimp Bada Bing and Calamari Fritti - perfect for sharing!
- Pasta Dishes: Signature offerings such as Spaghetti & Meatballs and Penne Alla Vodka showcase the authentic Italian essence. Each dish bursts with freshness and flavor!
- Baked Dinners: Indulge in comforting favorites like Baked Ziti Sicilian or Gnocci Sorrentina, ensuring a delightful conclusion to your meal.
Whether you’re dining in their inviting outdoor space or ordering for delivery, Benito's promises a memorable Italian dining experience.
Appetizers Pasta Baked Dinners Chicken Veal Pizza Benito's Gourmet PIZZA Salads 12" Sandwiches Desserts SOUP OF THE DAY Side Orders Stromboli Calzones Beverages TURNOVERS Bottle Red Wine Bottle White Wine HOUSEWINE Bottle Beer PT Beer Kid's Menu Pizza Takeout Specials Seafood Open Food LUNCH BUFFETT LUNCH - Appetizers LUNCH - Salads LUNCH - Pasta LUNCH - Baked Dinners LUNCH - Chicken LUNCH - Sandwiches LUNCH - Desserts LUNCH - Kids Menu Catering
Appetizers
$$ OPEN ITEM
$0.00
Garlic Cheese Bread
$8.00
Fresh Mozz Caprese
$11.00
Mussells Apt
$15.00
Shrimp Bada Bing
$14.00
Fried Mozz Carozza
$9.00
Escargot
$11.00
Fried Cheese Ravioli
$11.00
Shrimp Cocktail
$11.00
Baked Stuffed Mushrooms
$11.00
Calamari Fritti
$14.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$17.00
Spageti Primavera
$16.00
Tortell Alla Pana
$18.00
Spagh Carbonara
$17.00
Garlic & Olive Oil
$13.00
Sausage and Meatballs
$17.00
Meat Sauce
$16.00
Marinara Sauce
$13.00
Penne Alla Vodka
$20.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
$15.00
Pasta
Baked Dinners
Gnocci Sorrentina
$20.00
Sg & Peppers Ziti
$24.00
Eggplant Parm w/Spag
$16.00
Baked Ziti Sicilian
$16.00
Baked Ravioli
$17.00
Baked Cannelloni
$16.00
Pasta Combo
$16.00
Baked Manicotti
$16.00
Baked Lasagna
$17.00
Chicken Wings 10 Pc
$15.00
Grilled Ck Breast
$20.00
Chicken Saltimbocca
$20.00
Chicken Alla Rosa
$20.00
Chicken Marsala
$20.00
Chicken Picata
$20.00
Chicken Francese
$20.00
Chicken Scarparello
$20.00
Chicken Parm
$20.00
Chicken
Veal
Veal AllaRosa
$25.00
Veal Picata
$25.00
Veal Francese
$25.00
Veal Saltimbocca
$25.00
Veal Marsala
$25.00
Veal Scarparello
$25.00
Veal Parm
$25.00
16" Large Cheese
$15.99
12" Medium Cheese
$12.99
Pizza
Benito's Gourmet PIZZA
16" Margharita Pizza
$21.63
16" Mediterr Pzz
$20.00
12" Mediterr Pzz
$15.00
16" MeatLoverPzz
$20.00
12" MeatLoverPzz
$18.00
16" SeafoodPzz
$30.00
12" SeafoodPzz
$26.00
16" Hawaiian Pizza
$20.00
12" HawaiianPzz
$16.00
16" VeggiePizza
$20.00
12" VeggiePizza
$18.00
16" Chkn PestoPzz
$20.00
12" Chkn PestoPzz
$20.00
16" WhitePizza
$20.00
12" WhitePizza
$17.00
12" MargheritaPzz
$18.00
16" BenitosPizza
$20.00
12" BenitosPizza
$18.00
16" BBQ Chkn Pzz
$20.00
12" BBQ Chkn Pzz
$15.00
16" SupremePizza
$20.00
12" SupremePizza
$15.00
Side Salad
$4.00
Chef Salad
$15.00
Antipasto Salad
$17.00
Caesar Salad
$12.00
Greek Salad
$14.00
Garden Salad
$9.00
Benito's Salad
$15.00
Salads
12" Sandwiches
Chicken Parm Sub
$15.00
Eggplant Parm Sub
$15.00
Meatball Parm Sub
$15.00
Ham & Cheese Sub
$15.00
Italian sub
$15.00
Grilled Chicken Sub
$15.00
Cheese Steak Deluxe Sub
$15.00
Cheese Cake
$6.00
Zeppole
$6.00
Cheese Cake w/ Strawberry Sauce
$6.00
Tiramisu
$6.00
Cannoli
$6.00
Desserts
SOUP OF THE DAY
Copy of Soup of the Day
$4.33
Soup of the Day
$5.20
Sd Meatsauce
$5.00
Bowl Of Soup
$8.00
Cup Of Soup
$4.00
Side Dressing
$1.50
Sd Anchovies
$2.00
Side Blck Shrimp
$9.00
Side Gr Shrimp
$7.00
Side Blck Chicken
$9.00
Side Gr Chicken
$9.00
Side Marinara 4- oz
$3.00
Side Alfredo 4- oz
$4.00
Rolls - 2 Pc
$1.50
Rolls 4 Pc
$2.00
Side Pasta w/Marinara
$8.00
Sd Spinach & Garlic
$8.00
Sd Mixed Vegetables
$8.00
Sd Broccoli & Garlic
$8.00
Side Sausage
$8.00
Side Meatballs
$8.00
Sd French Fries
$5.00
Side Orders
Stromboli
Large Stromboli
$28.00
Small Stromboli
$20.00
MeatloversTurnOver
$15.00
Steak-OnionTrnOver
$15.00
Sg-PeppersTrnOver
$12.00
Florentina TrnOver
$15.00
Cheese Calzone
$12.00
Calzones
Beverages
Diet Pepsi
$2.60
Pepsi
$2.60
Coke Zero
$2.60
Root Beer
$2.60
Soda Refill
$1.00
Dr. Pepper
$2.60
Bottle of Water
$0.50
Pellegrino
$7.00
Coffee Decaf
$2.60
Un-Sweetened Tea
$2.60
Panna Water
$7.00
Coffee
$2.60
Sweet Tea
$2.60
Lemonade
$2.60
Mr. Pibb
$2.60
Sprite
$2.60
Diet Coke
$2.60
Coke
$2.60
Copy of Sausage and Peppers Turnover
$17.31
Copy of Meat Lovers Calzone
$19.47
Copy of Florentina
$17.31
Copy of Cheese Calzone.
$12.98
Meat Lovers Calzone
$15.00
Steak and Onions Turnover
$15.00
Sausage and Peppers Turnover
$12.00
Florentina
$15.00
TURNOVERS
Bottle Red Wine
Cork Fee
$15.60
B Greg Norman Cab
$40.00
B Murphy G Cab
$40.00
B Chianti Classico
$40.00
B Trinity Oaks Merlot
$40.00
B Greg Norman Blend
$40.00
B Josh L Rd Blnd
$40.00
B DP Malbec
$40.00
B Meiomi P Noir
$40.00
B HobNob PN
$40.00
Pinot Noir
$40.00
B Kendall J Chrd
$40.00
B Ruffino Prosecco
$7.28
B Jacob's Creek Moscato
$40.00
B Toasted H Chard
$40.00
B Mark W Chard
$40.00
B Kim Crwf Sauv Blanc
$40.00
B JoelG Sauv Blanc
$40.00
B Ste. Riesling
$40.00
Bottle White Wine
HOUSEWINE
Reisling
$7.83
Full Carafe WZin
$40.00
Full Carafe Sangria W
$40.00
Full Carafe Sangria R
$40.00
Full Carafe Lambrusco
$40.00
Full Carafe Pg
$40.00
Full Carafe Chard
$40.00
Full Carafe Chianti
$40.00
Full Carafe Merltot
$40.00
Full Carafe Cab
$40.00
White Zin
$7.00
Merlot House
$7.00
Cabernet House
$7.00
Chardonnay House
$7.00
White Sangria House
$7.00
Red Sangria House
$7.00
Lambrusco House
$7.00
Pinot Grigio House
$7.00
Chianti House
$7.00
Yuengling
$4.50
B Amstel Light
$6.00
B Budweiser
$4.50
B Corona Light
$4.50
B Corona Extra
$4.50
B Heineken
$4.50
B Mich Ultra
$4.50
B Peroni
$4.50
B Miller Lite
$4.50
B Bud Light
$4.50
Bottle Beer
PT Beer
Pt Bud Light
$12.48
Pt Stella
$20.80
Pt I-10
$20.80
Pt Blue Moon
$20.80
Pt Green Room
$20.80
Pt Dukes
$20.80
Pt Miller L
$12.48
Pt Sam Adams
$20.80
Pt Yuengling
$12.48
Pt Ultra
$12.48
Pt Bud L
$12.48
Kids Chicken Fingers w/Fries(Lunch)
$10.00
Kids Alfredo
$8.00
Kids Chkn Finger & Fries
$10.00
Kids Spaghetti w/Meatballs
$10.00
Kids 10" Cheese Pizza
$10.00
Kids Chicken Parm w/Spaghetti
$10.00
Kids Chicken Fingers w/Fries
$10.00
Kids Baked Lasagna
$10.00
Kids Baked Ziti
$8.00
Kids Ravioli (Cheese or Meat)
$8.00
Kids Sausage or Marinara Sauce
$10.00
Kids Spaghetti w/Marinara Sauce
$9.00
Kid's Menu
Pizza Takeout Specials
16" Chz To Spcl
$10.99
16" Large 2 Topping
$12.99
16" Large 1 Topping
$11.99
Fra Diovola
$26.00
Scampi
$26.00
Frude Di Mare
$31.20
Linguini w/Red Or White Clam Sauce
$20.80
Calamari Over Linguini
$21.63
Seafood
Open Food
Open Food
$0.00
Lunch Buffet 12-3 PM Kids under 12yrs.
$8.99
Lunch Buffett 12-3 pm Adult
$11.99
LUNCH BUFFETT
LUNCH - Appetizers
Fried Cheese Ravioli (Lunch)
$9.99
Shrimp Bada Bing (Lunch)
$9.99
Fried Mozz Carozza (Lunch)
$9.99
Calamari Fritti (Lunch)
$9.99
Antipasto Salad (Lunch)
$9.99
Garden Salad (Lunch)
$9.99
Caesar Salad (Lunch)
$9.99
Benito's Salad (Lunch)
$9.99
Greek Salad (Lunch)
$9.99
LUNCH - Salads
LUNCH - Pasta
Penne Alla Vodka (Lunch)
$10.00
Tortell Alla Pana (Lunch)
$10.00
Spagh Carbonara (Lunch)
$10.00
Garlic & Olive Oil (Lunch)
$10.00
Fettuccine Alfredo (Lunch)
$10.00
Meat Sauce (Lunch)
$10.00
Marinara Sauce (Lunch)
$10.00
Sausage and Meatballs (Lunch)
$10.00
Sg & Peppers Ziti (Lunch)
$10.00
Baked Ravioli (Lunch)
$10.00
Gnocci Sorrentina (Lunch)
$10.00
Baked Lasagna (Lunch)
$10.00
Baked Ziti Sicilian (Lunch)
$10.00
Eggplant Parm w/Spag (Lunch)
$10.00
Baked Cannelloni (Lunch)
$10.00
Pasta Combo (Lunch)
$10.00
Baked Manicotti (Lunch)
$10.00
LUNCH - Baked Dinners
LUNCH - Chicken
Grillled Chicken Breast Over Veggies(lunch)
$10.00
Chicken Francese (Lunch)
$10.00
Chicken Parm (Lunch)
$10.00
Chicken Alla Rosa (Lunch)
$10.00
Chicken Marsala (Lunch)
$10.00
Chicken Picata (Lunch)
$10.00
Meatball Parm Sub(Lunch)
$8.00
Grilled Chicken Sub(Lunch)
$8.00
Ham & Cheese Sub(Lunch)
$8.00
Italian sub(Lunch)
$8.00
Chicken Parm Sub(Lunch)
$8.00
Eggplant Parm Sub(Lunch)
$8.00
LUNCH - Sandwiches
LUNCH - Desserts
Cheese Cake (Lunch)
$6.24
Tiramisu (Lunch)
$6.49
Cannoli (Lunch)
$6.24
Kids Chicken Parm w/Spaghetti.(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Alfredo(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Ravioli (Cheese or Meat).(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Baked Lasagna(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Spaghetti w/Meatballs.(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Sausage or Marinara Sauce(Lunch)
$9.00
Kids Spaghetti w/Marinara Sauce.(Lunch)
$9.00
LUNCH - Kids Menu
Catering
Garlic Rolls - Per Dozen
$6.00
Eggplant Parmigiana - Full Tray
$160.00
Eggplant Parmigiana - Half Tray
$80.00
Chicken Alla Rosa - Full Tray
$180.00
Chicken Alla Rosa - Half Tray
$90.00
Chicken Marsala - Full Tray
$180.00
Chicken Marsala - Half Tray
$90.00
Chicken Alfredo - Full Tray
$190.00
Chicken Alfredo - Half Tray
$90.00
Chicken Parmigiana - Full Tray
$160.00
Chicken Parmigiana - Half Tray
$80.00
Meatball / Sausage - 50ct
$125.00
Meatball / Sausage - 25ct
$75.00
Spaghetti w/ Meat Sauce - Full Tray
$160.00
Spaghetti w/ Meatsauce - Half Tray
$80.00
Spaghetti Marinara - Full Tray
$120.00
Spaghetti Marinara - Half Tray
$60.00
Ravioli Cheese - Full Tray
$140.00
Ravioli Cheese - Half Tray
$70.00
Manicotti - Full Tray
$140.00
Manicotti - Half Tray
$70.00
Sausage & Peppers w/Ziti - Full Tray
$140.00
Sausage & Peppers w/Ziti - Half Tray
$70.00
Baked Ziti - Full Tray
$120.00
Baked Ziti - Half Tray
$60.00
Lasagna - Full Tray
$180.00
Lasagna - Half Tray
$90.00
Greek Salad - Full Tray
$90.00
Greek Salad - Half Tray
$45.00
Benitos Salad - Full Tray
$90.00
Benitos Salad - Half Tray
$45.00
Garden Salad - Full Tray
$70.00
Garden Salad - Half Tray
$35.00
Caesar Salad - Full Tray
$90.00
Caesar Salad - Half Tray
$45.00